Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
You are standing in the kitchen at 7 a.m. with a puppy who has just done the right thing for the fourth time in ten minutes. What you hand over in that moment decides whether the lesson sticks. A big biscuit slows the session down and piles calories onto a body that is still growing. A tiny, low-calorie training treat keeps the reps coming, keeps your pup focused, and keeps you from overfeeding a dog that only weighs a few pounds. That is the whole game with puppy training treats — small enough to repeat, tasty enough to matter, and gentle enough that a young stomach can handle dozens a day. Below you will find the nine options worth comparing, from a bag of 400 bacon treats down to a freeze-dried liver pouch that costs more per ounce.
This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
Puppies learn fastest through repetition, so the treat you pick has to be one you can hand out constantly without thinking twice. Every option here is either made for puppies or rated for all life stages, and each one earns its place for a different reason. Read on for the puppy training treats that hold up session after session.
Top Picks
How To Choose The Best Puppy Training Treats
A training treat has one job: get eaten fast so the lesson keeps moving. A puppy that has to stop and gnaw on a big biscuit loses the thread of what you were teaching. That single idea — speed of eating — should shape almost every choice you make here. Once you have that straight, the rest is matching the treat to your puppy’s teeth, stomach, and your own habits.
Size and calorie count are the first filter
In a single puppy session you might hand out twenty or thirty rewards. At 3 calories each, that is a normal snack. At a much larger calorie load per piece, you are quietly feeding a second meal. Look for treats described as low calorie per piece and small enough that you do not have to break them up. A pencil-eraser-sized piece is about right for a puppy learning “sit.” Slightly bigger is fine for a large-breed pup.
Soft versus crunchy
Soft treats get chewed and swallowed in a second or two, which keeps your pace up. Crunchy treats give a young dog something to work at, which can hold attention longer but also slows the rhythm. Neither is wrong. Soft suits puppies still figuring out their teeth and older dogs with fewer of them. Crunch works well for dogs that need a beat to focus, and it tends to stay intact in a pocket instead of smearing.
Ingredients your puppy’s stomach can handle
Young dogs have sensitive digestion, and you are asking them to eat a lot of these little pieces. Simple recipes with a single named meat first tend to be easier on a pup than long ingredient lists. Watch for artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives if you want to keep things plain. If your puppy has a known allergy, the allergen information on the bag is worth reading before you commit to a large bag.
Will it fit your training gear?
If you use a treat pouch, a clicker, or a treat-tossing camera, the shape of the treat decides whether it works. Soft pellets fit snugly in a pouch. Small discs and pellets pass through dispensers without jamming. Larger chunks need breaking first. Think about how you actually train before you buy a 400-count bag.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Model | Best For | Calories Per Treat | Texture | Bag Size | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Charlee Bear Original Crunch, Liver, 3-Pk★ Best Overall | All-round puppy training | 3 | Crunchy disc | 6 oz (3-pack) | Amazon |
| Brutus & Barnaby Sweet Potato & ChickenBest for Dispensers | Dispenser and pouch use | — | Soft pellet | 0.23 kg | Amazon |
| The Honest Kitchen Meaty LittlesBest Ingredients | Human-grade ingredients | 2 | Soft chew | 4 oz | Amazon |
| Crazy Dog Train-Me! Bacon | Big bag, heavy repetition | 3 | Soft chewy | 16 oz / 400 treats | Amazon |
| Blue Buffalo Bits Chicken | Soft treats for young teeth | — | Soft pellet | 19 oz | Amazon |
| Finley’s Turkey Training Bites | Breaking in half for tiny reps | 2 or less | Soft pellet | 16 oz | Amazon |
| Bully Max Puppy Training Treats | Added joint and brain support | — | Soft chew | 16 oz | Amazon |
| Charlee Bear Crunch, Chicken Pumpkin Apple 2-Pk | Small mouths and senior dogs | 3 | Crunchy disc | 16 oz (2-pack) | Amazon |
| Lick You Silly Freeze-Dried Beef Liver | Single-ingredient high value | — | Freeze-dried chunk | 8.16 oz | Amazon |
Detailed Reviews
1. Charlee Bear Original Crunch Dog Training Treats 3-Pk
Our pick — 4.5+★ from 900+ verified ratings; the strongest balance of quality and price.
Three calories a piece, three bags in the box, and a crunch that keeps a puppy working.
For the puppy owner who wants one bag that handles obedience class, crate training, and the walk around the block, this is the one to start with. Each treat carries 3 calories, so you can reward a young dog fifty times in an afternoon and still be inside a sensible snack budget. That number is the reason this pick sits at the top — a puppy needs repetition, and repetition needs a treat that does not punish you for using it.
The texture is the other half of the story. These are pocket-perfect discs, which means they sit flat in a treat pouch or a jacket pocket without turning into grease or crumbs. A puppy has to actually chew one, and that brief pause is exactly when you mark the behavior. Owners consistently come back to how clean they are to carry — nothing smears, nothing sticks to the lining of a pouch. The liver flavor does the rest, pulling food-motivated puppies straight back to you after a distraction.
This is also, quietly, the most versatile option on the list. The discs are small enough for a young puppy learning “sit” and still meaningful for an adult dog working on a stay. One owner reports her dogs have stayed on these for 13 years as the only treat that never caused upset. The honest trade-off: the crunch is loud and it makes crumbs when a dog chews it on a rug. Bag packaging also has room to improve — one buyer received a bag crushed in transit. Neither is a reason to pass, but pair these with a pouch if you train indoors.
Where this one earns the top spot
- 3 calories per treat, so a long session stays a snack and not a meal
- Crunchy disc keeps a puppy engaged without slowing training to a crawl
- Pocket-friendly shape means no grease or crumble in a treat pouch
- Three bags per order, so you keep one at home, one in the car, one in a training kit
What to expect in real life
- The crunch produces crumbs if you train on carpet
- Bag packaging has arrived crushed for some buyers
- Liver flavor is rich; a picky puppy may need a trial before a big order
Start here if: you want one low-calorie treat that covers obedience, crate training, and walks without overfeeding a growing puppy.
Think twice if: your puppy turns their nose up at liver — the rich flavor is not for every dog.
2. BRUTUS & BARNABY Training Treats Sweet Potato & Chicken
Small, soft pellets built to drop out of a treat dispenser without jamming — or to leave a pouch clean.
If your training setup involves a treat-tossing camera or a puzzle toy, this is where the conversation starts. The pellets are sized to fit a Furbo and most dispensers, and the listing calls out that they do not jam or leave residue. A dispenser that clogs mid-session breaks your puppy’s focus and your own rhythm in the same second. Small soft pieces also mean a puppy chews and swallows fast, so there is no lag between the reward and the next command.
Real chicken and sweet potato, no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives, and a low-calorie label on the bag. The soft texture suits a small puppy still working out its teeth. The aroma is the training engine here — a strong smell is what pulls a distracted puppy back to you, and this bag leans into that deliberately. What wins people over is simply that dogs want them; the treats are ranked for pet preference above everything else in owner feedback, and that enthusiasm is the raw material every training session runs on. As one owner put it: “Doug’s been mastering so many new tricks lately, and Brutus & Barnaby training treats are his secret weapon!”
The catch is size on the other end of the scale. These are small-breed pellets, and buyers who train larger puppies or go through a lot of treats in a week wish the bag came bigger. There is a firmness to them too — soft, but not squishy — which is good for clean pockets and slightly less forgiving for a puppy with very little chewing experience. A dog that is not strongly food-motivated may treat these as a nice snack rather than a high-value reward.
Who it fits: the puppy parent running a Furbo, a treat pouch, or a puzzle feeder who wants pellets that drop cleanly and get eaten instantly.
The honest limit: the bag runs small on volume, so heavy trainers will burn through it and may want a bigger format.
Reach for this if: your training happens through a dispenser or a puzzle toy and you want pellets that never jam.
Look elsewhere if: you have a large-breed puppy who needs a bigger reward and a bigger bag.
3. The Honest Kitchen Meaty Littles Puppy Treats
Two calories of human-grade lamb and salmon per piece, small enough that no breaking is needed.
This is the bag for the puppy parent who reads ingredient labels before they read the price tag. The human-grade recipe leads with real lamb and salmon and skips GMO ingredients, corn, wheat, soy, meat meals, and artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors. It is also marked for a limited ingredient diet. For a puppy with a sensitive stomach or a household that keeps things plain, that short list is the whole reason to pick it.
Each piece is a tender mini meat treat at 2 calories, and the bag names DHA, pumpkin, vitamin E, and omegas as part of the recipe. In plain terms, you are rewarding with something closer to real food than a biscuit. The pieces are small enough that the listing says no breaking is needed, which matters when you are handing out a reward every few seconds and do not want to stop to snap a treat in half. Puppy owners describe them as the perfect tiny training bit, and the soft texture is easy on a mouth full of new teeth.
The 4-ounce bag is where this pick asks you to think ahead. It is the smallest bag on this list, and the treats are proportionally the most expensive way to train — one buyer flagged that plainly, noting the small package is costly even though the ingredients are clean and made in the USA. That is a real trade-off, not a flaw. Buy this as your high-value reward for the hard lessons, and keep a cheaper bulk bag for the easy repetitions. Two buyers also mention that even a dog that dislikes salmon will eat these, which tells you the flavor blend hides the fish.
What stands out: 2 calories per piece with human-grade lamb and salmon, and no corn, wheat, soy, or meat meals anywhere in the recipe.
Size reality check: a 4 oz bag goes fast in daily training — plan this as your premium reward, not your everyday bulk supply.
Pick this for: a puppy with a sensitive stomach whose owner wants the shortest, cleanest ingredient list on the shelf.
Weigh first: the 4 oz bag is small and priced accordingly — fine as a high-value treat, harder to justify as your only bag.
4. Crazy Dog Train-Me! Training Treats Bacon 16 oz
Four hundred three-calorie bacon bites in one bag — enough for weeks of daily puppy sessions.
Volume is the headline. A 16-ounce bag holding 400 treats means you stop rationing. One bag gives you 400 individual rewards, each at 3 calories, so a puppy in the thick of house training can be paid constantly without the bag running dry. Compare that to a 4-ounce specialty bag and the difference in how freely you can reward is obvious. Natural pork liver and natural bacon lead the recipe, with no corn, soy, or artificial flavors. The texture is soft and chewy, so the treat goes down fast and training keeps moving.
What makes this one stand apart is how well the pieces behave in gear. The treats are described as pencil-eraser sized, which is small enough for a puppy and small enough to drop into a treat-tossing camera or load into a puzzle toy. A dog trainer says in so many words that these are the treats she trains with, and dogs will do just about anything for them. Owners also note the pieces stay soft rather than going stale, which is unusual for a bag this large.
That small size cuts both ways. For a trainer working fast with a puppy, a tiny soft piece is perfect. For a dog that has already mastered a trick and needs a meaningful payoff, it may read as too small. The bacon smell is strong and it lingers on your fingers after a session, which is the price of a treat dogs find this compelling. If you plan to load these into a dispenser, note that buyers recommend filling the hopper only halfway and keeping the rest sealed so the treats do not dry out and crumble.
The volume argument: 400 treats per 16 oz bag at 3 calories each lets you reward generously for weeks without reordering.
The catch: the strong bacon scent stays on your hands, and the tiny pieces may feel too small as a jackpot reward.
Best match for: someone in the middle of daily house training who needs a big supply of fast, low-calorie rewards.
Not for you if: your puppy needs a substantial treat to feel rewarded — these are deliberately tiny.
5. Blue Buffalo Bits Chicken Training Treats, 19 oz
Soft, tender pellets with real chicken first and a 19-ounce bag that outlasts most training programs.
The puppy owner who wants to reward often without pushing a puppy past its calorie budget has a soft-treat favorite here. Chicken is the first ingredient, the treats are low calorie, and they are enhanced with DHA, an omega-3 fatty acid the bag calls out for cognitive development. For a young puppy in its first months of learning, that is a nice bonus to a reward you were going to give anyway.
The texture is what owners respond to. These are soft and tender, which suits a puppy with new teeth and also works for an older dog that struggles with hard biscuits. They are small heart-shaped pellets, easy to chew and quick to swallow, so the training pace stays where it should. The training-friendly nature of these treats is the thing owners praise most, with taste right behind it — meaning a dog both wants the treat and can use it as a reward. If you have ever had a puppy lose interest halfway through a session, that combination is the fix.
The catch is the smell. The recipe uses chicken and omega fatty acids, and the bag itself draws mixed reactions, with some buyers finding the aroma fine and others finding it strong. Step downwind before you open the bag and it is a non-issue. The other thing to plan around is the size of the bag. Nineteen ounces is generous, and a puppy will not get through it fast, so store it sealed to keep the treats fresh.
What you get in the bag
- Real chicken as the first ingredient with a low-calorie formula
- Soft, tender texture that suits puppies and older dogs alike
- DHA for cognitive development and omega fatty acids for skin and coat
- 19 oz bag holds up through weeks of sessions without a reorder
Points worth knowing
- Aroma draws mixed reactions — some buyers find it strong
- Large bag means longer storage; reseal it to keep treats fresh
- Soft texture is easy to chew, but less durable for high-energy tugging
The match for: anyone training a puppy with sensitive teeth or a senior dog who still needs a reward.
Where it falters: the strong chicken aroma is the one thing buyers either love or dislike.
6. Finley’s Training Treats Turkey 16oz
Two calories or fewer per soft bite, and each one breaks in half when a puppy needs a tiny reward.
The early weeks of puppy training are a numbers game. A young pup needs dozens of rewards a day, and the treat you choose has to make that easy on the waistline. Finley’s puts real turkey as the number one ingredient and keeps each treat at 2 calories or less, which is about as low as you can go while still offering actual meat. The bag also lists them as high protein and free of corn, wheat, rye, and soy, with no artificial colors, flavors, or added sugar.
Soft and small, these pellets are designed for quick chewing. The detail that makes them genuinely useful in training, though, is how easily they snap in half. Puppy owners lean on that constantly in early sessions when you reward every correct step, and one owner sums it up this way: “I like using these for puppy training bc they’re easy to break in half which is useful when you’re giving lots and lots of treats in those early days.” They also stay firm enough not to crumble, so a treat pouch does not end up full of dust.
A 16-ounce bag is generous, which makes this a solid everyday pick for heavy repetition. The one honest caution is freshness. Several buyers report the treats dry out once the bag is open, turning crumbly if you do not reseal it well. Keep it clipped shut, or move the treats into an airtight container, and that problem stays small. The bag also supports a charitable mission, which is a nice extra for buyers who care where their money goes.
Why it earns its spot: 2 calories or fewer, real turkey first, and a soft texture that snaps in half for tiny rewards.
What to watch: open-bag freshness — these dry out fast if the bag is not resealed tightly.
Worth grabbing if: you want a low-calorie soft treat you can split in two for those fast early training sessions.
Look past it if: your puppy has a known poultry sensitivity and you need a completely different protein.
7. Bully Max Puppy Training Treats Soft Chews
A training treat that doubles as a puppy multivitamin, with 22% protein and a beef flavor.
Most training treats are empty calories by design — that is the point of them. Bully Max takes the other road. These soft chews carry 22% protein, DHA for brain development, glucosamine and chondroitin for joint health, and omega-6 for skin and coat. The bag lists them for puppies from 4 weeks up, in small, medium, and large breeds. If you were going to reward a puppy anyway, this is a bag that layers in functional nutrition while doing it.
The soft chewy texture suits young puppies and small breeds, and the beef flavor is a strong motivator for a puppy that needs to be pulled back to focus. They can also be crushed as a food topper, which is useful if your puppy is a picky eater and you want to make a bowl of kibble more appealing. They are made in the USA with globally sourced ingredients, and the brand states zero recalls. For a puppy you are training daily, that reliability is worth considering.
The pieces are also smaller than the bag photo suggests, which some buyers find surprising given the large pouch. It is a soft chew, so it does not hold up in a pocket for long before squashing. Keep it in the bag or the pouch, not loose in your jeans, and the texture stays where it should.
The pitch: a 22% protein beef soft chew with DHA, glucosamine, and chondroitin, made in the USA for puppies 4 weeks and up.
The honest side: it is priced like a supplement rather than a treat, so it suits buyers who want the added nutrition and not just a quick reward.
Fits your routine if: you want one bag that rewards a puppy and also delivers joint and brain support.
Skip the splurge if: you go through treats at high speed and a plain low-calorie bag would do.
8. Charlee Bear Crunchy Dog Training Treats 8oz 2-Pack
Mini crunchy discs for toy breeds and puppies, in a two-bag pack that keeps one flavor consistent.
The trainer working with a tiny puppy or a small-breed dog knows how easy it is to hand out a treat that is simply too big. These discs are built for the opposite situation. They are mini crunchy bites sized for small and toy breeds, puppies, and older dogs with less jaw strength, and each one runs about 3 calories. The 2-pack delivers two full-size bags in the same Chicken, Pumpkin, Apple flavor, so you avoid changing the taste a dog recognizes mid-training.
Crunch does something useful here beyond taste. A dog has to stop and chew it, which is a brief pause you can use to mark and then move on to the next cue. The treats are grainfree and made in the USA with USA-sourced ingredients. What gets talked about most is simply that dogs want them, followed by the low-calorie formula — and the reviews back that up with a range of personalities, from a helpful dog at work to a lab that will eat anything. The light crunch suits a senior dog too; one owner with a dog down to a few teeth reports they are crunchy but not too hard.
The trade-off with a two-pack of 8-ounce bags is storage. You now have two open bags to keep fresh, so plan where the second one goes before you open it. The discs also make crumbs when chewed hard, like any crunch treat, so train over tile or outside if the rug matters. Two full-size bags’ worth means you can keep one at home and one in the car without running through your supply.
Why it stands out: a 2-pack of 8 oz bags in one consistent Chicken, Pumpkin, Apple flavor, with mini discs at roughly 3 calories each.
The trade-off: two open bags need storing, and the crunch leaves crumbs behind on carpet.
The one to pair with: a toy-breed or small puppy that needs a mini treat gentle on small jaws.
Think again if: you have a large-breed puppy — these discs may vanish too quickly to feel like a reward.
9. Lick You Silly Freeze-Dried Beef Liver Dog Treats
One ingredient, nothing else — the treat you keep in reserve for the hard lessons.
Some puppies will walk past a biscuit and stare at you. For that dog, you need a reward that outranks everything else in the room. This is that bag. It is 100% freeze-dried beef liver, sourced from USDA-inspected beef liver, with no fillers, grains, or artificial additives. Grain-free and marked easy to digest, it is a good fit for puppies with sensitive stomachs or those on a limited diet. It is also labeled human-grade.
The 8.16-ounce bag holds chunks rather than neat discs, so you break off what you need from each piece. Puppies and full-grown dogs alike respond to it — one owner’s 13-year-old dachshund with sensitive digestion handled these without upset. It also works beyond training: use it as a meal topper or crumble it over food to make a picky puppy eat. The bag is resealable, which keeps the freeze-dried texture from going soft between sessions.
Be honest about the price and the size. At 8.16 ounces, this is the most expensive bag on the list to train from, and owners mention so plainly — it is a premium treat for a reason. The chunk format is the other thing to plan for. Pieces vary in size, and larger ones need breaking before you reward a toy breed. Buyers also note an odd odor that some find off-putting. Buy this as your high-value reward for the tough stuff, not as the everyday bag you hand out like candy.
The standout: a single-ingredient freeze-dried beef liver, USDA-inspected, human-grade, and grain-free — the highest-value reward on the list.
The catch: a premium price for an 8.16 oz bag, plus varied chunk sizes that need breaking and an odor some buyers dislike.
Choose this when: your puppy ignores ordinary treats and you need a reward that will not be walked past.
Not the right pick if: you want an everyday bag to reward constantly — the cost per session is simply too high.
Know the Specs
Calories Per Treat
This is the number that controls how freely you can reward. A puppy in early training might earn fifty treats in a single day. At 2 or 3 calories each, that stays a sensible snack rather than a second dinner. At a much higher figure, you are feeding your puppy without meaning to. Most bags list this, and the good low-calorie training treats land at 2 or 3. Buy the lowest number you can get while still keeping a reward your dog actually wants.
Treat Size and Shape
Size decides training speed. A tiny piece gets chewed and swallowed in seconds, so your puppy stays focused. A large biscuit forces a pause long enough to break the rhythm. Shape matters too: discs and small pellets sit flat in a pouch, while chunks need breaking. If you use a dispenser or a puzzle toy, check whether the piece fits before you buy a big bag. When in doubt, smaller is better for puppy training.
Soft Versus Crunchy Texture
Soft chews suit puppies with new teeth and older dogs with fewer of them. They go down fast and leave no mess in your pocket. Crunchy treats give a dog something to work at, which can hold attention, and they tend to stay intact in a pouch. Neither is better than the other — match it to your dog. A puppy that bolts its food may benefit from crunch that forces a pause.
Ingredients and Allergens
You are handing out a lot of little pieces, so the recipe matters. A short list with a named meat first tends to suit young stomachs better than a long one with fillers. Watch for artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives if you want to keep things clean. If your puppy has a known sensitivity, check the allergen information on the bag. Grain-free and limited-ingredient options suit some dogs; others do fine on grains.
Bag Size and Freshness
A big bag saves you reordering and lets you reward generously. The catch is time. Treats can dry out once the bag is open, especially soft ones, and stale treats are hard to motivate a puppy with. Pick a bag size you can finish in a reasonable window, and reseal it well or transfer the contents to an airtight container. Freeze-dried treats stay fresh longer in a sealed bag but still need protection from moisture.
Dispenser and Pouch Fit
If your training setup runs through a treat pouch, a dispenser camera, or a puzzle toy, the treat has to fit. Small pellets work in most pouches and dispensers. Discs sit flat and stay put. Larger chunks need breaking first. Buy a small bag first if you are unsure, then upsize once you know the shape works in your gear.
Common Questions
How many training treats can I give a puppy in one day?
Are soft or crunchy treats better for puppy training?
Will puppy training treats work in a Furbo or other treat dispenser?
Can I use adult dog treats for puppy training?
Do grain-free treats suit every puppy?
How do I stop training treats from going stale?
Are these treats gentle enough for a puppy with a sensitive stomach?
What size treat is right for a small puppy?
Can training treats replace a meal?
Which training treats are the best value for heavy daily use?
How we choose
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of October 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, How Dog Care earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.